Pro Forma Assignment
*price is negotiable
>Assumptions
Assignment # – Assumptions
0,000
x total net leasable area
0%
8.50% per sq. ft. , others
per sq. ft. per sq. ft. 0.0% -10 of lease
2.00% Legal Fees 1.00% 50% 5.0%
75% 3 1 Market rents
space 1 0% of market rent – 20% step in year 6 of their lease
2 15,000 5 $4.31 $64,700 0 1 sign 5 year lease @ market rent $0.00 15,000 2 sign 5 year lease @ market rent $0.00 10,000 3 sign 5 year lease @ market rent $0.00 4 sign 5 year lease @ market rent $0.00 Capital Expenses
20 10 &A &P of &N
Law firm Law firm Law firm Law firm Law firm (life of lease) – Old Leases
Operating Expense Recovery Operating Expenses Vacancy Allowance Stabilized NOI s
IRR on Flow IRR on Flow Net Operating Income Capital Expenditures (repair / replacement / renovations / additions)
, CCA recapture, terminal loss
&”Lucida Grande,Regular”&11&K000000C307 Pro-Forma Assignment Answers &”Lucida Grande,Regular”&K000000&A &”Lucida Grande,Regular”&11&K000000&P of &N
The object of this analysis is to give you some experience in creating a pro-forma for analysing the attractiveness of an individual project. Assumptions necessary for the
proforma analysis are attached; use them to examine a seven-year investment in a higher
quality retail centre. The pro-forma should be in nominal dollars. Use the following rules:
i) use a single discounting rate or IRR; ii) no carry forward of operating losses for use
against future income; iii) assume year 0 as the year of acquisition followed by 10 full
years of income, with sale at end of year 10, iv) the purchase includes the maximum
allowable loan, and vi) unless otherwise indicated, all leases are 5 year net leases, vii)
sale price based on estimated year 11 stabilized NOI, viii) passive owner & only one
property. For stabilized income: i) Calculate gross potential rent using current average
rent per occupied sq ft., ii) use actual operating costs, iii) vacancy allowance use the
average occupancy rate in the building over the holding period years 1-10, iii) deduct
estimated average Tis and leasing costs. Assume all TIs and leasing costs are deductible
over the life of the lease.
READ THE ASSUMPTIONS CAREFULLY
1. Purchase Price (150 points – approximately)
Find the acquisition price that gives you a total before tax unleveraged return (CFO and
capital revenues and expenditures) of 600 bp over the yield of a Government of Canada
benchmark bond yield – 10 year (as reported Friday Feb. 4, 2013,
http://www.bankofcanada.ca).
a. Take the maximum “allowable” 1st mortgage.
b. Assume that your three listed primary tenants renew, while all other tenants renew with
the assumed renewal probability. If there is no renewal use the assumed months vacant.
c. Lease terms by tenant are in the rent roll.
d. You have scheduled recoverable capital expenses. These are assumed to be added to
the UCC
All further questions refer to the after tax leveraged return for total cash flow (CFO
and capital revenues and expenditures) that came out of your calculation in 1.
2. Sensitivity Analysis (60 points). Test for the effect on your returns for a change in each of the following variables (these
are independent not cumulative). Provide the change in basis points (bp) in your return
and the before and after values in your lowest year’s CFO (lowest year is lowest year
after change)
a. Rate of rent appreciation falls to 3.5%
b. Rate of expense appreciation increases to 4%
c. Cap rate at sale is 9.5%
d. Months vacant increases to 6 months
e. Probability of renewal falls to 50%
f. New tenant TIs increase by 5$ psf
3. Downturn (40 Points)
How do your return annual CFO, and sales price change if all of the following changes
occur that create a downturn during your holding period over years 3-6?
a. Market rents fall by 5% per annum for years 3-4, and are then flat year 5
b. Market rents rise by 13% % per annum years 6-8 and then resume the assumed growth
rate
c. Renewal probability falls to 50% for years 3-5 and returns to the original assumption in
year 6
d. Time vacant rises to 11 months for years 3-4 and then 9 months in year 5 before
returning to the original assumption for years 6 and on
4. Main Tenant Leaves (80 Points)
Your largest tenant goes bankrupt at the end of year 3.
a. What is your return and cash flow over years 4-6 if you take the 60,000 square feet and
lease it out to smaller tenants as follows: i. They will all sign 5 years standard leases
ii. The space is vacant for 6 months, then you sign new tenants at a rate of 10,000 sq ft
per quarter
b. How long (months) could you wait to get a new main tenant and get the same return as
in a? What would be the cash flows years 4-6 if you do this?
c. If you double TIs for the new main tenant, how would your answer in “b” change? Q1 Purchase price (rounded to $000) _______________________
Q2a bp change in IRR ______ Q1 AFTCF_________ New AFTCF_______ Year _____
Q2b bp change in IRR ______ Q1 AFTCF_________ New AFTCF_______ Year _____
Q2c bp change in IRR ______ Q1 AFTCF_________ New AFTCF_______ Year _____
Q2d bp change in IRR ______ Q1 AFTCF_________ New AFTCF_______ Year _____
Q2e bp change in IRR ______ Q1 AFTCF_________ New AFTCF_______ Year _____
Q2f bp change in IRR ______ Q1 AFTCF_________ New AFTCF_______ Year _____
Q3 bp change in IRR ______ New Sales Price __________
Year 3 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 3 New ATCF _________
Year 4 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 4 New ATCF _________
Year 5 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 5 New ATCF _________ Year 6 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 6 New ATCF _________ Year 7 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 7 New ATCF _________
Year 8 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 8 New ATCF _________
Year 9 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 9 New ATCF _________
Year 10 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 10 New ATCF _________
Q4a IRR ______
Year 4 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 4 New ATCF _________ Year 5 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 5 New ATCF _________
Year 6 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 6 New ATCF _________ Q4b Months ______
Year 4 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 4 New ATCF _________ Year 6 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 6 New ATCF _________ Q4c Months ______
Year 4 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 4 New ATCF _________
2
C
3
0
7
1
Buildng Size
Total
Stabilized NOI
Net Leasible Area
1
8
Gross rent revenues: use average rent of occupied
space
Vacancy Allowance
Use average vacancy rate for years 1-
10
Sales Price
Bad Debt Allowance
1.00%
Cap Rate at Sale (on stabilized NOI)
8.
5
Expected annual TIs & Leasing costs as % of rent revenue
Operating
Expenses
Yr 1 Costs
Loan Calculations
1st Mortg.
CAM, Utilities, property tax, & management (all recoverable)
per sq. ft.
$10.00
Min allowed DCR
1.25
Insurance (not receoverable)
$2.00
Max LTV
0.75
Annual increase in expenses , includes
Tis
3.0%
Amortization Period (years)
20
Rate = basis points spread over prime
150
Leasing Expenses
TI (New)
$20.00
Sales Costs
TI (renew)
$5.00
Commission
1.
75%
TI costs allocated to lease
10
0.0%
Legal Fees
0.50%
TI costs allocated to structure
Leasing/brokerage fees
Purchase Costs
% of total net rent paid over years 1-5 of lease
3.50%
Taxes
2.00%
% of total net rent paid over years
6
Leasing costs (renew)
of costs for new
Tax Treatment
CRU Renewals & Vacancies
Marginal Tax Bracket
4
Probability CRU tenant renews
Market value of structure @ Purchase
80.0%
of purchase price
Expected time space is vacant
months
Market value of structure @ Sale
60.0%
of sales price
Revenues
Year
Per Sq. Ft.
$21.00
Annual Increase in Rents
4.5%
Rent Roll
Tenant
Years left on lease
Current lease terms (renew at same)
Current rent
Current lease TI/sq ft
TIs received for current lease
Leasing Agent Fees for Current Lease
Law firm
60,000
10 year lease @
9
$18.56
$3.83
$229,800
$136,900
Mortgage brokers
15,000
Signs 7 year lease@ market rent – 15% step in year 4 of their lease
$21.61
$4.31
$64,700
$40,900
Engineering firm
Signs 10 year lease@ 95% of market rent – 10% step in year 3 of their lease and again in year 7
$19.63
$76,300
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 0
20,000
sign 5 year lease @ market rent
$18.79
$0.00
$86,200
$57,500
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 1
10,000
$19.21
$77,700
$21,000
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 2
$19.64
$89,300
$29,600
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 3
$20.09
$89,500
$26,400
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 4
35,000
$20.54
$169,800
$116,400
Scheduled
Recoverable
Amount
Years to Amortize (life of system)
Year 3 – Repair, replace with improvement over original
$1,000,000
Year 7 – Repair, replace original with same
$250,000
Recoverable from tenants as straight line expense for life of system
Unrecoverable Capital Expenses
Annual as % of initial structure value
0.25%
repair, same as original, no improvement
Q1
QUESTION 1 – BASELINE
Purchase Price
Year 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Parameters
Rent Growth
Expense Growth
Forecast Market rent psf (per sq ft)
Operating Expenses (psf)
Cleaning & Maintenance
Regular capital replacement (to original)
Insurance
Total
Recoverable Component
Tis
New
Renewal
Probability of renewal
Months to find new tenant (Max of 23)
Probability of renew-renew
Probability of renew-vacant or vacant-renew
Probability of vacant-vacant
Months vacant if renew-renew
Months vacant if renew-vacant / vacant-renew
Months vacant if vacant-vacant
Vacancy Allowance
Bad Debt Allowance
Cap rate at sale
Effective Occupied Space (average leased over year)
Law firm
Mortgage brokers
Engineering firm
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 0
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 1
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 2
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 3
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 4
Total Occupied
Vacancy Rate
Average Rent (psf) by Tenant/Tenant Group
Mortgage brokers
Engineering firm
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 0
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 1
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 2
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 3
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 4
Rent Revenues
Mortgage brokers
Engineering firm
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 0
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 1
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 2
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 3
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 4
Total Rent Revenues
Operating Expense Recovery
Mortgage brokers
Engineering firm
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 0
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 1
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 2
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 3
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 4
Total Operating Expense Revenues
Leasing Costs
Leasing Fees to Agents
Mortgage brokers
Engineering firm
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 0
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 1
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 2
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 3
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 4
Tenant Improvements (Tis)
Mortgage brokers
Engineering firm
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 0
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 1
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 2
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 3
Tenants w/ leases expiring end of year 4
Total Leasing+Tis Costs
Leasehold CCA Amount
Amortized Leasing Fees
Amortized Tis – Old Leases
Amortized Leasing Fees (life of lease) – New Leases
Amortized Tis – New Leases
Total
CASH FLOW CALCULATIONS (NOI & CFO)
Rental Income
Space Rent
Recovery of extra repair/replacement cost (to original quality or less)
Gross Income
Operating Expenses
Recoverable
Non-recoverable
Other Repair/replacement cost (to original quality or less)
Net Operating Income
Regular Capital Expenditures
Leasing costs & Tis
Cash From Operations
Stabilized NOI Calculation
Gross potential rent revenues
Operating expense recovery
Potential Gross Income
Bad Debt Allowance
Effective Gross Income
Operating recoverable
Non-recoverable operating expenses
Stabilized (Annualized) Leasing & Tis
Expenses
Primary Loan
Payment
Property Before Tax Cash Flow (PBTCF)
Income Tax Owed (No Loss Carry Forward)
Property After Tax Cash Flow (PATCF)
CAPITAL ACCOUNT: Purchase & Reversion
Purchase Price/Sales Price
Costs at Purchase/Sales
Loan Contribution/Repayment
Capital expenditure (improvement)
Capital expenditure recovery (improvement)
Tax on
Capital Gain
Tax on CCA Recapture
CFO + Reversion
IRR on Flow
BTPCF + Equity Reversion
ATPCF + After Tax Reversion
Debt Calculations
Loan Data – Primary Loan
Outstanding Balance (Beginning of Period)
Payment
Interest
Principal
Amortized Fee
Outstanding Balance (End of Period)
Tax Calculations
Taxable Income
Interest+Amortized Fee
Pre-CCA Taxable Income
CCA DEDUCTIONS
Leasehold Deductions
Amortized Leasing Fees
Amortized Tis – Leasehold Improvements
Amount to Deduct
Pre Structure CCA Taxable Income
Structure CCA Deductions
UCC- Start of Period
Intial Structure
Start of Year UCC
New (TIs) – improvement to structure
Structure
Max CCA Eligible
CCA Used
End of Year UCC
Total CCA taken to date
Adjusted Cost Base (ACB)
Taxable Income (Excld CCA Recapture)\
Income Tax (cash flow only, excld CCA reversion taxes)
CCA Recapture & Capital Gains
Values at Sale
Land (Market=Book Value)
Structure
Market value
Book value = UCC
Adjusted Cost Base
Adjust Land/Structure Value (if land capital gain & structure terminal loss)
Adjusted structure value
Adjusted land value
Capital gains/loss, CCA recapture, terminal loss
Land Capital Gain/Loss
Structure capital gain
Structure recapture
Structure capital gains
Terminal loss
CCA Recapture (taxable as income)
SALES PRICE, Revenue & Capital Gains
Sales Price before adjustment for capital reimbursement
PV of future structure repair/improvement payments
Gross Sales Price
Charges at Sale
Real Estate Commission
Legal Fees
Capital Gain
Land capital gain
Structure capital gain
Sales Charges
Net Capital Gains
Capital Gains Tax (credit)
CALCULATION AREA
Return Calculations
Yield on 10 yr Treasury
Yield on 10 yr Treasury (after tax)
BP spread of desired return
Target IRR
Year 5 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 5 New ATCF _________
Year 5 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 5 New ATCF _________
Year 6 Initial AFTCF_________ Year 6 New ATCF _________