English Essay

 

hapter One: Thinking and Reading: a Critical Connection p 1 – 10 –

Jon Carroll:

The Problem With New Data

p. 5

Reading Question: What is Critical Thinking and why is it Important? What does Carroll mean by “brain lock” issue? Response should be at least one page. Use examples from the book to illustrate your explanation.

Critical and Analytical Thinking

Critical thinking
Word ‘critical’ has positive and negative meanings
The word ‘critical’ in academia describes your attitude when reading an article/chapter
Being critical means weighing up the arguments for and against a particular point.

*
Not just the bad parts

How to think critically
Be persistent – consider an issue carefully more than once
Look at the evidence for a viewpoint – evaluate it – what are they trying to ‘sell’ me?
What are the implications of a view point – is it realistic and rational?
Knowing facts and what is right is not what academics is about
It is important to identify strengths, satisfactory points and weaknesses when being critical – then you must know why this is so
You should be critical when reading, writing and listening

*
Need to fully understand an argument before you can be critical – be confident
Evaluate=what is the value/effectiveness of something, inc. own opinion and supporting each point with evidence
Question the credibility
You are just assessing ideas not learning the answers
Only want informed opinions

Analytical thinking
Being analytical mean to look deeper into what is being said
Do not take what you read as ‘given’
Evaluate what is being argued – do you agree with it?
To be analytical is to question what you read

*
Not just reading what is said but ‘thinking’ about it

How to think analytically
Think about the view point in relation to the bigger picture – stand back
Compare the same issue from the point of other authors – do their views differ?
Should be able to see why authors have arrived at different conclusions
You should be able to argue why you think one set of view points is preferable to another
You should be analytical when reading, writing and listening

*
Think about your readings together, put into context
You should be asking why a conclusion has been made – need full understanding for this

Barriers to critical and analytical thinking
Being critical does not just mean criticise
Our reasoning skills are not objective – we are biased ourselves
Reluctance to criticise experts
Wanting to know what is right and wrong
Not reading deeply enough around a subject – surface knowledge

*
Not always black and white there are lots of grey areas in academics
Being analytical and critical is hard work, you have to read carefully and widely

Critical and analytical reading
Prepare for critical reading – skim read the introduction and conclusion
Find the conclusions first to help clarify the rest of the reading
What is the underlying argument/ view point?
Question hidden agendas or assumptions
Theory can help fill in the gaps – what is theory?
– set of ideas to explain why something happens and predict outcomes in the future
Arguments are often based on theory but an argument is not always a theory

Critical and analytical reading
Where is the evidence for a view point?
Check references – are they presented accurately and are they credible? – evaluate that evidence – date, source, bias, statistics
Does the evidence support the conclusions made?
Taking notes that support critical reading
Read without a pen in your hand to avoid taking down lots of unnecessary notes
Form a set of questions to help you think more deeply about what you have read

Critical and analytical reading
Statement: Childhood is fluid and is represented differently within the various institutions in our society; these representations change over time.
Form a Question Bank:
Why? What does this really mean? Do the reasons support the argument? Is there any supporting evidence? Does this match what I know about the subject already? Does it fit in with what other people have said on the subject? Is this relevant and useful to my current purpose? How does this add to previous research on the subject? Are there any flaws in this? What is the author trying to ‘sell’ me?
You can apply these questions and similar ones to all of your arguments and essays to encourage you to question why things are the way they are – before, during and after reading
Questioning

*
Brainstorm activity

Critical and analytical writing
You should question your own assumptions and biases as much as you do other authors
Ask yourself questions – why have you used a certain example, what are you trying to argue, where is the theory to support your argument?
Plan your argument before you start writing – what is the question/ problem, what are the view points surrounding the problem, which do you agree with, why? Mind Map
Do not be afraid of critically analysing works by people you know are more experienced than you

*
Think of yourself as an impartial adjudicator, you can be critical without having to completely take one side

Tony Buzan

Critical and analytical writing
There are difference ways of presenting an idea – description, explanation, critical analysis (see next slide)
In academic writing it is not enough to simply describe an idea or theory
Description – an account of how something is done, or what something is like
Explanation – same structure as an argument but they do not attempt to persuade the reader to a particular point of view
Critical analysis – a judgement of an idea giving reasons and evidence to support your decision, you must look at ideas in detail

Description, explanation or analysis? Example:
Attachment theory states that children become attached to adults who remain as consistent caregivers for some months during the period from about 6 months to two years of age.

Attachment theory states that children become attached to adults who remain as consistent caregivers for some months during the period from about 6 months to two years of age. It is suggested that this is due to the trusting bond developed from the repeated interactions with certain individuals.

Attachment theory states that children become attached to adults who remain as consistent caregivers for some months during the period from about 6 months to two years of age, and it is suggested that this is due to the trusting bond developed from the repeated interactions with certain primary carers. However, there are many cases of abused children who form strong attachments to their abusers despite being subjected to severe neglect suggesting that there are problems with this theory of attachment.

Critical and analytical writing
You can see that analysis takes a greater length of discussion than an explanation. It is better to analyse and criticise a few points in an essay than try to superficially discuss lots of ideas

Your own arguments within your essay need supporting evidence
All ideas and arguments must be supported by evidence to add credibility

For example:
– ‘In my experience I have found that in school, girls are more obedient and attentive, whilst boys are more challenging and disobedient’ – not credible
– ‘It can be suggested that in school girls are more obedient and attentive, whilst boys are more challenging and disobedient; this idea is supported by arguments put forward by Bleach (1992) and Channer (1995) who argue…..’ – credible

Critical and analytical writing
Has anything been written about the subject already? – where can I find this information
Which are the most relevant and authoritative sources for this subject?
Recognise where evidence is relevant or irrelevant – does it support the conclusions of the point, what conclusions can you draw from the evidence
We should not generalise from a single case, in academics this is unacceptable – generalisations should be well-founded and based on a reasonable sample – think about this when reading the works of others
Use your question bank to encourage you to look at your own work with critical eyes
Evaluate your own writing – use a critical and analytical checklist (Stella Cottrell handout)

Critical and analytical thinking
Never take anything you have read or been told as ‘given’ – question everything
Use evidence and theory to back up all of your arguments and statements – do not simply describe; analyse and criticise
Being analytical and critical is hard work but the more you practice the easier it will become
The more you read the easier it will be to think critically and analytically
Be confident in what you are arguing and why you arguing it