Business Question

Please read the word document carfully 200 word count for each question, add all the answers to page 11 in the word document

Ethics Guidelines And Social Responsibility -To do

How do the firms deal with the domestic cultures of the countries they operate in?

What are the firms’ ethics guidelines, and how is the firms’ culture shaped and defined?

How has the firm seen its social responsibility in its environment?

How do the firms respond to their environment, including the rules and regulations of the host country?

Global and financial strategy -To do

How do the firms assess their global competitive environment, and how have they designed strategies to deal with it?

Have the firms entered a strategic alliance with another company? How and why?

How have the firms established efficient value-added chain activities?

How do the firms finance their projects, and how have they invested in other related or unrelated ventures?

How do the firms allocate financial resources?

1
Project-3
Comparison between The Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra and
Maruti Suzuki
MGMT-511 Digital and Global Enterprises
Professor: Bryan D. Little
Team Members
Aayushi Maheshwari
Hamad Abdullah A Almanee
Xiaoran Liu
Yinzhile Luo
2
Instruction: (to be deleted later)
In your book: Multinational Management, there are a few Integrating Cases. Please choose of
one these cases:
Shell Oil in Nigeria
Organizational and National Cultures in a Polish-U.S. Joint Venture
Tata Motors
The Fleet Sheet
Transition to Whirlpool Tatramat: From Joint Venture to Acquisition
Cisco Switches in China: The Year of Manager
Then research for two other companies that you could compare with this case. These cases could
be found in a variety of sources. For example, if you choose Tata Motors, you have to choose
two other car manufacturers who have pursued almost similar strategies in the market and
compare the three together. In this comparison, you should concentrate on major themes
addressed in Tata (your chosen case) case.
Example of the Themes in Tata: Government and Demographic Shift in India, Automobile
Industry in India, International Business Initiatives of Tata, Growth strategy, Global Market
Positioning of Tata, Partnering with other Global Companies
In the comparison, pinpoint differences, similarities, strength, weaknesses and finally success
and failures.
From the Syllabus
Project 3 on a Real Company
The research and company report will exercise the student’s ability to consume, synthesize, and
apply what is learned in the class, the reading assignments, the research materials, and the
concepts discussed and clarified in the course. The same team of students who worked on
Projects 1 & 2 will assess and evaluate at least two global companies of their choosing in the
same industry and write a report on them. They must utilize primary sources on the companies in
writing their reports and follow scholarly methods in conducting research, organizing the report,
and citing references (in-text and references page). Students must concentrate on critical
questions and information that accurately depict how the selected companies perform in the
global marketplace and
establish their competitive advantage.
In Project 3, students must explore the following questions in their selected companies.
1) What is the organizational structure of the firms?
2) What are the firms’ product, service, and marketing strategies?
3) How have the firms established their decision-making model?
3
4) How do the firms approach environmental challenges in the context of Michael Porter’s
model?
5) How do the firms deal with the domestic cultures of the countries they operate in?
6) What are the firms’ ethics guidelines, and how is the firms’ culture shaped and defined?
How has the firm seen its social responsibility in its environment?
7) How do the firms respond to their environment, including the rules and regulations of the
host country?
8) How are the firms’ resources and capabilities assessed in the global market?
9) How do the firms market and distribute their products and services?
10) Have the firms participated in a regional integration mechanism?
11) How do the firms allocate financial resources?
12) How have the firms established a supply-chain management system?
13) How do the firms deal with foreign exchange?
14) How have the firms expanded in the global market, how have they entered new markets
with new products, and how have they retreated from some markets?
15) How have the firms established efficient value-added chain activities?
16) How do the firms finance their projects, and how have they invested in other related or
unrelated ventures?
17) How do the firms assess their global competitive environment, and how have they
designed strategies to deal with it?
18) Have the firms entered a strategic alliance with another company? How and why?
19) How do the firms approach supply-chain management processes?
20) Do the firms have a solid global human resource management process?
21) How do firms approach technological needs, intellectual capital resource building, and
management?
22) How did the adoption of new technologies by the firms impact their technological
structure and decision-making?
23) How do firms approach digitalization and e-commerce in their business processes?
24) Has the firm embraced the concept of virtual teams in its operation?
Project 3 is a written report; no slides are necessary. Students will post a copy of their report on
Canvas before the assigned deadline
The paper is to have 8,000 to 10,000 words. You should have a cover page, a Table of Contents,
the Table of Contents must also have the names of the students tasked with completing each
section, a References page, in-text citations. and whatever else you deem appropriate.
Company we are going to compare:
1) Tata Group
2) Mahindra & Mahindra
3) Maruti Suzuki
There are 25 questions and the required 8k words minimum, we need on average of 320 words of
answers for each question.
Resources: (Links of external reading sources you found about these 3 companies)
4
Table of Contents
Company Background – Angela ………………………………………………………………………………………. 6
What is the organizational structure of the firms?…………………………………………………………………… 6
What are the firms’ products, service, and marketing strategies? ……………………………………………. 7
How have the firms established their decision-making model? ………………………………………………… 8
How do the firms approach environmental challenges in the context of Michael Porter’s model? 9
How do firms approach digitalization and e-commerce in their business processes? ……………….. 10
Ethics Guidelines And Social Responsibility -To do ………………………………………………………… 11
How do the firms deal with the domestic cultures of the countries they operate in? ………………… 11
What are the firms’ ethics guidelines, and how is the firms’ culture shaped and defined?……….. 11
How has the firm seen its social responsibility in its environment? …………………………………………. 11
How do the firms respond to their environment, including the rules and regulations of the host
country? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 11
Global and financial strategy -To do ………………………………………………………………………………. 11
How do the firms assess their global competitive environment, and how have they designed
strategies to deal with it?………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 11
Have the firms entered a strategic alliance with another company? How and why?………………… 11
How have the firms established efficient value-added chain activities? …………………………………… 11
How do the firms finance their projects, and how have they invested in other related or unrelated
ventures? …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 11
How do the firms allocate financial resources? ……………………………………………………………………… 11
Local Market – Aayushi ………………………………………………………………………………………………… 12
How do the firms market and distribute their products and services? ……………………………………. 12
Have the firms participated in a regional integration mechanism? …………………………………………. 13
Global Market and Foreign Exchange – Aayushi ……………………………………………………………. 15
How are the firms’ resources and capabilities assessed in the global market? …………………………. 15
How have the firms expanded in the global market? ……………………………………………………………… 17
How have they entered new markets with new products, and how have they retreated from some
markets? ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 18
How do the firms deal with foreign exchange? ………………………………………………………………………. 20
Organizational Management – Xiaoran ………………………………………………………………………….. 22
How have the firms established a supply-chain management system?…………………………………….. 22
How do the firms approach supply-chain management processes?…………………………………………. 23
Do the firms have a solid global human resource management process? ………………………………… 24
5
How do firms approach technological needs, intellectual capital resource building, and
management? ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 25
How did the adoption of new technologies by the firms impact their technological structure and
decision-making? …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 26
Has the firm embraced the concept of virtual teams in its operation? …………………………………….. 27
References …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 29
6
Company Background – Angela
What is the organizational structure of the firms?
Tata Group
The Tata Group operates with a highly diversified and decentralized organizational structure.
Comprising over 100 operating companies spread across various sectors such as steel,
automobiles, information technology, telecommunications, and hospitality, each company
functions as an independent entity. Tata Sons Limited, the principal investment holding company
and promoter of Tata companies, plays a pivotal role in providing strategic direction and
oversight. Each company within the Tata Group has its own board of directors and management
team, enabling them to operate with considerable autonomy while adhering to the overall vision
and ethical standards of the group. This decentralized structure allows each company to be agile
and responsive to market conditions while benefiting from the synergies and strengths of the
larger group.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Mahindra & Mahindra operates with a hybrid organizational structure that combines centralized
strategic planning with decentralized operational control. The corporate center provides strategic
oversight and ensures that all business units align with the overall vision and mission of the
Mahindra Group. However, each business unit, such as automotive, agribusiness, aerospace, and
IT, operates with considerable autonomy, making decisions that are responsive to their specific
market conditions and operational needs. This structure allows Mahindra to leverage synergies
across its diverse businesses while maintaining the agility and responsiveness required to
succeed in their respective markets.
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki, a subsidiary of Suzuki Motor Corporation, operates with a centralized
organizational structure influenced significantly by its parent company. This structure ensures
that Maruti Suzuki aligns with Suzuki’s global vision, strategies, and standards while also
catering to the specific needs of the Indian market. The company’s management is comprised of
both Japanese and Indian executives, fostering a blend of global best practices and local market
insights. This hybrid structure allows Maruti Suzuki to leverage Suzuki’s global expertise in
automotive manufacturing and technology while maintaining a strong local presence and
understanding of the Indian automotive market.
Aspect
Structure
Strategic
Oversight
Operational
Autonomy
Local vs Global
Focus
Table 1: Comparison of Organizational Structures
Tata Group
Mahindra &
Maruti Suzuki
Mahindra
Decentralized
Hybrid
Centralized
Tata Sons Limited
Corporate center
Suzuki Motor Corporation
High
Moderate
Moderate
Global strategy with
local autonomy
Balanced global and Global strategy with local
local strategy
implementation
7
What are the firms’ products, service, and marketing strategies?
Tata Group
The Tata Group’s product and service offerings are extensive and diverse, reflecting its presence
in numerous industries. Tata Motors is known for its range of automobiles, from commercial
vehicles to passenger cars, including electric vehicles like the Tata Nexon EV. Tata Steel is a
global leader in steel production, focusing on high-quality, sustainable steel solutions. TCS (Tata
Consultancy Services) is a global IT services giant, providing consulting, IT infrastructure, and
business solutions.
Marketing strategies within the Tata Group are tailored to the specific needs and characteristics
of each sector but generally emphasize the core values of quality, innovation, trust, and social
responsibility. For instance, Tata Motors’ marketing campaigns highlight reliability and
innovation, targeting different customer segments with messages tailored to their specific needs,
from rugged commercial vehicles to sophisticated passenger cars.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Mahindra & Mahindra is a diversified company with a strong presence in automotive
manufacturing, agribusiness, aerospace, information technology, and more. The company’s
automotive segment, including brands like Mahindra and SsangYong, is known for its range of
utility vehicles, trucks, and electric cars. In agribusiness, Mahindra provides tractors and farm
equipment, emphasizing productivity and sustainability. Mahindra’s marketing strategies are
centered on innovation, durability, and the “Rise” philosophy, which underscores the company’s
commitment to driving positive change and empowering stakeholders. This philosophy is
reflected in their advertising campaigns, which often highlight the company’s focus on
technological innovation, reliability, and social responsibility. For instance, Mahindra Thar’s
marketing emphasizes its ruggedness and adventure-ready capabilities, appealing to a younger,
outdoor-oriented demographic.
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki focuses exclusively on the automotive sector, offering a wide range of vehicles
that cater to different market segments, from affordable hatchbacks like the Alto and Swift to
premium models like the Ciaz and S-Cross. The company’s product strategy emphasizes
affordability, fuel efficiency, and reliability, which resonate well with Indian consumers. Maruti
Suzuki’s extensive service network, with over 3,600 service touchpoints across India, ensures
that customers have easy access to maintenance and repair services. Marketing strategies at
Maruti Suzuki are designed to reinforce the brand’s core values of trust, affordability, and
widespread availability. The company invests heavily in advertising through various media
channels, including television, print, digital, and social media, to reach a broad audience. Their
marketing campaigns often focus on highlighting the value-for-money proposition, fuel
efficiency, and the extensive after-sales service network, which are critical factors for Indian car
buyers.
Table 2: Comparison of the product, service and marketing strategies
Aspect
Tata Group
Mahindra & Mahindra
Maruti Suzuki
Product
Diverse (steel,
Diverse (automotive,
Focused (automobiles)
Range
automobiles, IT,
agribusiness, aerospace,
telecom)
IT)
8
Marketing
Focus
Key
Campaigns
Quality, innovation,
trust, social
responsibility
Brand value and social
responsibility
Innovation, durability,
empowerment
“Rise” philosophy
Affordability, fuel
efficiency, service
network
Value-for-money,
widespread availability
How have the firms established their decision-making model?
Tata Group
The decision-making model at Tata Group is characterized by a balance of centralized strategic
oversight and decentralized operational autonomy. While Tata Sons provides strategic guidance
and ensures that the companies align with the group’s overarching mission and values, individual
companies enjoy the freedom to make operational decisions independently. This model promotes
agility and responsiveness at the operational level while maintaining strategic coherence and
ethical integrity across the group. The Tata Code of Conduct, which outlines the ethical
principles and values that all Tata companies must adhere to, serves as a crucial framework
guiding decision-making processes across the conglomerate.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Mahindra & Mahindra employs a combination of centralized and decentralized decision-making
processes. Strategic decisions, particularly those involving large investments, new market
entries, or significant shifts in business strategy, are made at the corporate level. However, dayto-day operational decisions and tactical adjustments are decentralized, empowering individual
business units to act swiftly in response to market dynamics. This decision-making model allows
the company to remain strategically aligned while being operationally agile. The company’s
commitment to governance and ethical standards, outlined in the Mahindra Code of Conduct,
ensures that decisions are made with integrity and transparency.
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki employs a hybrid decision-making model that combines centralized strategic
directives from Suzuki Motor Corporation with localized decision-making to address the unique
needs and preferences of the Indian market. While strategic decisions related to product
development, technology adoption, and major investments are influenced by Suzuki’s global
strategies, operational decisions, and market-specific strategies are developed locally. This
approach ensures that Maruti Suzuki remains aligned with global standards while being highly
responsive to local market dynamics. The company’s governance structure includes a robust
framework of ethical standards and compliance mechanisms, ensuring that decision-making
processes uphold the highest standards of integrity and transparency.
Aspect
Centralization
Table 3: Comparison of Organizational Structures
Tata Group
Mahindra &
Mahindra
Decentralized
Hybrid
Maruti Suzuki
Centralized with
local autonomy
9
Strategic
Decisions
Independent by company
within group framework
Corporate center
Influenced by Suzuki
Operational
Decisions
High autonomy
Decentralized
Moderate autonomy
Ethical
Framework
Tata Code of Conduct
Mahindra Code of
Conduct
Compliance with
Suzuki standards
How do the firms approach environmental challenges in the context of
Michael Porter’s model?
Tata Group
In the context of Michael Porter’s model, Tata Group addresses environmental challenges
through innovation and sustainable practices across its diverse portfolio. Tata Steel, for instance,
has implemented numerous initiatives to reduce its carbon footprint, such as adopting energyefficient technologies and increasing the use of renewable energy sources in its operations. Tata
Motors has invested heavily in electric vehicle technology, positioning itself as a leader in the
transition to sustainable transportation. The group’s sustainability strategy is integrated into its
business operations, focusing on long-term environmental stewardship and aligning with global
sustainability goals.
Mahindra & Mahindra
In addressing environmental challenges, Mahindra & Mahindra aligns with Michael Porter’s
model by integrating sustainability into its core business strategies. The company is a pioneer in
electric vehicle development in India, with models like the eVerito and the e2o Plus. They have
also invested in renewable energy projects, such as solar power, through Mahindra Susten, and in
sustainable farming practices through Mahindra Agribusiness. Mahindra’s approach to
environmental sustainability involves reducing its carbon footprint, enhancing energy efficiency,
and promoting the use of renewable resources. The company’s initiatives, such as the “Mahindra
Hariyali” initiative, aim to plant millions of trees across India, reflecting its commitment to
environmental stewardship and community development.
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki addresses environmental challenges by focusing on enhancing fuel efficiency,
developing hybrid and electric vehicle technologies, and adopting green manufacturing practices.
The company has introduced several fuel-efficient models and is investing in the development of
hybrid vehicles, such as the Maruti Suzuki Ciaz SHVS. Additionally, Maruti Suzuki has
implemented energy-efficient technologies in its manufacturing processes and has set ambitious
targets for reducing carbon emissions and increasing the use of renewable energy sources.
In line with Michael Porter’s model, Maruti Suzuki seeks to create a competitive advantage
through sustainability. By offering environmentally friendly vehicles and adopting green
practices, the company not only complies with regulatory requirements but also meets the
growing consumer demand for sustainable mobility solutions.
Table 4: Comparison of Organizational Structures
10
Aspect
Tata Group
Sustainability
Focus
Energy efficiency,
electric vehicles
Key Initiatives
Electric vehicles,
green manufacturing
Mahindra &
Mahindra
Electric vehicles,
renewable energy,
sustainable farming
Electric vehicles, solar
projects, tree planting
Maruti Suzuki
Fuel efficiency, hybrid
technology, green
manufacturing
Hybrid vehicles, emission
reduction targets
How do firms approach digitalization and e-commerce in their business
processes?
Tata Group
Tata Group has embraced digital transformation across its businesses to enhance efficiency,
innovation, and customer engagement. Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) plays a leading role in
driving digitalization initiatives not only within the group but also for external clients globally.
Tata Digital, a subsidiary focused on digital businesses, is at the forefront of developing and
integrating digital solutions across the group’s diverse businesses. This includes initiatives such
as Tata Neu, a super-app designed to offer a unified digital ecosystem for various Tata services
and products, ranging from e-commerce to financial services. This digital-first approach is aimed
at creating seamless, integrated experiences for customers, leveraging the group’s wide-ranging
expertise and resources.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Mahindra & Mahindra has integrated digitalization into various aspects of its business processes.
The company has embraced Industry 4.0 technologies in its manufacturing processes, including
the use of IoT, artificial intelligence, and big data analytics to enhance efficiency and
productivity. The DiGiSENSE platform connects Mahindra’s vehicles and equipment, providing
real-time data and analytics that improve operational efficiency and customer service.
In e-commerce, Mahindra has developed platforms such as SmartShift, which connects cargo
owners and transporters through a digital marketplace, and M2All, an online portal for
purchasing Mahindra vehicles and accessories. These digital initiatives not only streamline
operations but also enhance customer engagement and provide new avenues for growth.
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki has embraced digitalization to enhance customer experiences and streamline
operations. The company’s NEXA platform offers a digital car buying experience, allowing
customers to browse, configure, and purchase vehicles online. Maruti Suzuki Arena integrates
online and offline customer engagement, providing a seamless experience from research to
purchase.
Aspect
Table 5: Comparison of Organizational Structures
Tata Group
Mahindra & Mahindra
Maruti Suzuki
11
Digital
Led by TCS, Tata Digital
Transformation initiatives
Key Platforms
Tata Neu
Focus Areas
Seamless digital
ecosystem, customer
experience
Integrated in
manufacturing, customer
engagement
DiGiSENSE, SmartShift
Real-time data, digital
marketplaces
NEXA, Maruti
Suzuki Arena
NEXA, Maruti
Suzuki Arena
Online and offline
customer engagement
Ethics Guidelines And Social Responsibility -To do
How do the firms deal with the domestic cultures of the countries they operate in?
What are the firms’ ethics guidelines, and how is the firms’ culture shaped and defined?
How has the firm seen its social responsibility in its environment?
How do the firms respond to their environment, including the rules and regulations of the host
country?
Global and financial strategy -To do
How do the firms assess their global competitive environment, and how have they designed
strategies to deal with it?
Have the firms entered a strategic alliance with another company? How and why?
How have the firms established efficient value-added chain activities?
How do the firms finance their projects, and how have they invested in other related or unrelated
ventures?
How do the firms allocate financial resources?
12
Local Market – Aayushi
How do the firms market and distribute their products and services?
Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra, and Maruti Suzuki have distinct approaches to marketing
and distribution, tailored to their unique strengths and market segments. Here’s a detailed
comparison of their strategies.
Tata Motors
Marketing Strategy:
• Tata Motors focuses on a diversified marketing strategy that targets various market
segments including commercial vehicles, passenger cars, and luxury vehicles through its
acquisition of Jaguar Land Rover (JLR).
• They use a mix of traditional and digital marketing channels, emphasizing innovation,
safety, and sustainability.
• Tata Motors actively participates in auto expos and industry events to showcase new
models and technologies.
• The company leverages corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives to build brand
loyalty and enhance its public image (Aicl, 2024).
Distribution Strategy:
• Tata Motors has an extensive dealer network across India, ensuring wide accessibility to
its products.
• The company employs a multi-channel distribution approach, including direct sales,
dealerships, and online platforms.
• Internationally, Tata Motors has established a network of distributors and partners to
penetrate global markets (Kumar et al., 2021).
Mahindra & Mahindra
Marketing Strategy:
• Mahindra & Mahindra emphasizes its strong legacy in utility and agricultural vehicles,
often using themes of ruggedness and reliability in their marketing campaigns.
• The company engages heavily in rural marketing, utilizing local events and fairs to
promote their products.
• Digital marketing and social media campaigns have become increasingly important,
especially for their passenger vehicle segment.
• Mahindra leverages its sponsorships and CSR activities to enhance brand awareness and
customer engagement (Shastri, 2024).
Distribution Strategy:
• Mahindra & Mahindra has a robust distribution network with a strong presence in rural
and semi-urban areas.
• They use a combination of direct dealerships, authorized service centers, and online
platforms to distribute their vehicles.
• The company has developed strategic partnerships with local distributors in international
markets to enhance their global reach (Kumar et al., 2021).
Maruti Suzuki
13
Marketing Strategy:
• Maruti Suzuki focuses on affordability, fuel efficiency, and extensive service networks as
key marketing points.
• Their marketing campaigns are highly localized, addressing the needs and aspirations of
the Indian middle class.
• The company uses a mix of traditional advertising, digital marketing, and sponsorships to
reach a broad audience.
• Customer loyalty programs and extensive after-sales service are integral to their
marketing strategy (Shastri, 2022).
Distribution Strategy:
• Maruti Suzuki has the most extensive dealer and service network in India, ensuring high
accessibility and convenience for customers.
• They employ a dealership model combined with online sales platforms to cater to both
urban and rural markets.
• Maruti Suzuki has developed a strong network of authorized service centers to provide
reliable after-sales service, enhancing customer satisfaction and loyalty (Arora, n.d.).
Table 6: Comparison of Marketing and Distribution Strategies
Aspect
Tata Motors
Mahindra & Mahindra
Maruti Suzuki
Marketing
Traditional, digital,
Rural marketing, digital,
Traditional, digital,
Channels
auto expos, CSR
local events, sponsorships, localized campaigns,
initiatives
CSR
customer loyalty
programs
Distribution
Extensive dealer
Strong presence in rural
Extensive
Network
network, multiand semi-urban areas,
dealer/service
channel (direct,
direct dealerships, online
network, dealership
dealerships, online)
platforms
model, online sales
Global Presence International
Partnerships with local
Limited international
distributors, partners distributors in global
presence, focus on
markets
Indian market
Each company has tailored its marketing and distribution strategies to its strengths and target
markets. Tata Motors focuses on a diversified global presence, Mahindra & Mahindra
emphasizes rural and utility markets, while Maruti Suzuki targets the Indian middle class with a
robust service network.
Have the firms participated in a regional integration mechanism?
Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra, and Maruti Suzuki have engaged in various regional
integration mechanisms to enhance their market presence and operational efficiencies. Here’s an
overview of their participation and its implications.
Tata Motors
Regional Integration Mechanisms:
• SAARC: Tata Motors has leveraged the South Asian Association for Regional
Cooperation (SAARC) to expand its footprint in neighboring countries like Nepal, Sri
14
Lanka, and Bangladesh. This involvement has facilitated smoother trade and investment
flows within the region (Tata Motors, 2024).
• ASEAN: Through strategic partnerships and exports, Tata Motors has also engaged with
the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), particularly focusing on markets
like Thailand and Indonesia (Tata Motors, 2024).
Implications:
• Enhanced market access and reduced tariffs within SAARC and ASEAN regions.
• Greater collaboration with regional partners, leading to better supply chain management
and technology transfer.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Regional Integration Mechanisms:
• SAARC: Mahindra & Mahindra has also utilized SAARC to boost its presence in South
Asia. They have established manufacturing and assembly units in several SAARC
countries, facilitating easier market entry and expansion (The Mahindra Group Official
Website | Together We Rise, 2024).
• Africa: Although not a traditional regional integration mechanism like SAARC or
ASEAN, Mahindra has engaged with African regional bodies to penetrate markets in
South Africa, enhancing their international market scope (Kale et al., 2011; Pti, 2023).
Implications:
• Improved regional supply chains and cost efficiencies.
• Enhanced ability to meet local market demands through regional production and
assembly facilities.
Maruti Suzuki
Regional Integration Mechanisms:
• SAARC: Maruti Suzuki has focused on expanding its reach within the SAARC region by
exporting vehicles to countries like Nepal, Bhutan, and Sri Lanka. This strategy has been
instrumental in maintaining its dominant market position in South Asia (Kardar, 2011).
• Japan-India Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA): As a subsidiary
of Suzuki Motor Corporation, Maruti Suzuki benefits from the Japan-India CEPA, which
enhances trade and investment flows between the two countries.
Implications:
• Increased export opportunities and reduced tariffs within the SAARC region.
• Enhanced technological collaboration and investment inflows from Japan.
Table 7: Comparison of Regional Integration Mechanisms
Tata Motors
Mahindra & Mahindra
Maruti Suzuki
Active in SAARC,
Manufacturing units in
Exporting to Nepal,
expanding in Nepal, SAARC countries
Bhutan, Sri Lanka
Sri Lanka,
Bangladesh
Other Regional Engaged with
Engaging with African
Benefitting from
Mechanisms
ASEAN, focusing
regional bodies
Japan-India CEPA
on Thailand,
Indonesia
Aspect
SAARC
Participation
15
Implications
Enhanced market
access, reduced
tariffs
Improved regional supply
chains, cost efficiencies
Increased export
opportunities,
technological
collaboration
All three companies have strategically engaged in regional integration mechanisms to expand
their market reach and improve operational efficiencies. Tata Motors and Mahindra & Mahindra
have focused on broader regional engagements, including ASEAN and African markets, while
Maruti Suzuki leverages its connection with Japan through CEPA.
Global Market and Foreign Exchange – Aayushi
How are the firms’ resources and capabilities assessed in the global market?
Assessing the resources and capabilities of Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra, and Maruti
Suzuki in the global market reveals their strategic strengths and competitive positioning. Here’s a
comparative analysis:
Tata Motors
Resources:
• Financial Resources: Tata Motors has substantial financial backing, with strong support
from its parent company, Tata Group, providing it with the capability to invest in
research, development, and international acquisitions like Jaguar Land Rover (JLR)
(TATA MOTORS – 77th Integrated Annual Report 2021-22, n.d.).
• Technological Resources: Acquisition of JLR has significantly enhanced Tata Motors’
technological prowess, giving it access to advanced automotive technologies and luxury
vehicle manufacturing capabilities (Kale et al., 2011).
Capabilities:
• Innovation and R&D: Strong focus on innovation, especially in electric vehicles (EVs)
and sustainable technologies, positioning Tata Motors as a forward-thinking player in the
global market (Tata Motors, 2024).
• Global Supply Chain Management: Efficient global supply chain capabilities, bolstered
by international partnerships and local manufacturing units in key markets (Relationship
with Supply Chain Partners | Tata Motors Annual Report 2016-17, n.d.).
Mahindra & Mahindra
Resources:
• Diverse Product Portfolio: A wide range of products, including utility vehicles, tractors,
and two-wheelers, provides Mahindra & Mahindra with a strong market presence across
various segments (Broking, 2023).
• Financial Stability: Robust financial health supported by diversified business interests
across various sectors, including agribusiness, IT, and financial services (Financial
Services | Mahindra, n.d.).
Capabilities:
16
•
•
Strong Domestic Market Base: Dominance in the Indian market for utility and
agricultural vehicles, which provides a solid foundation for international expansion (The
Mahindra Group Official Website | Together We Rise, 2024).
Innovation in Electric Vehicles: Significant investments in EVs and renewable energy
technologies, aiming to capture a growing market for sustainable vehicles (Charging
Ahead – the Mahindra EV Story, 2020).
Maruti Suzuki
Resources:
• Market Leadership: Maruti Suzuki holds a dominant position in the Indian automotive
market, with a large customer base and extensive dealer network, which provides a strong
revenue stream and market insights (Success Story of Maruti Suzuki: A Journey of
Innovation and Market Leadership, n.d.).
• Technical Collaboration: As a subsidiary of Suzuki Motor Corporation, Maruti Suzuki
benefits from technological support and R&D capabilities from its Japanese parent
company.
Capabilities:
• Operational Efficiency: Highly efficient manufacturing processes and extensive supply
chain management, allowing for cost-effective production and timely delivery of
vehicles.
• Customer-Centric Approach: Strong focus on customer satisfaction and after-sales
service, which has fostered high customer loyalty and repeat business (Nvadmin, 2023).
Aspect
Financial
Resources
Technological
Resources
Innovation and
R&D
Global Supply
Chain
CustomerCentric
Capabilities
Table 8: Comparison of Resources in Global Market
Tata Motors
Mahindra & Mahindra
Maruti Suzuki
Substantial backing
Diversified financial
Strong revenue from
from Tata Group
stability
market leadership in
India
Advanced
Significant EV and
Technical support
automotive
renewable energy
from Suzuki Motor
technologies from
investments
Corporation
JLR
Focus on EVs and
Investing in EVs and
Efficient
sustainable tech
renewable energy
manufacturing and
supply chain
management
Efficient global
Strategic partnerships in
Extensive dealer
supply chains
global markets
network and service
centers
Strong focus on
Extensive after-sales
High customer
safety and
services in rural areas
loyalty and
sustainability
satisfaction
17
How have the firms expanded in the global market?
Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra, and Maruti Suzuki have utilized various strategies to
expand their presence in the global market. Here’s an in-depth look at their approaches.
Tata Motors
Strategic Acquisitions:
• Jaguar Land Rover (JLR): One of the most significant moves by Tata Motors was the
acquisition of Jaguar Land Rover in 2008. This acquisition not only provided Tata
Motors with access to luxury car markets but also advanced automotive technologies and
a strong brand presence in Europe and North America (Kumar et al., 2021).
Joint Ventures and Partnerships:
• Global Alliances: Tata Motors has formed strategic alliances with several international
companies to enhance its technological capabilities and market reach. Notable
partnerships include joint ventures with companies like Fiat and collaboration with
European and Chinese firms for electric vehicle technologies (Wikipedia contributors,
2024).
Market Penetration:
• Emerging Markets: Tata Motors has actively penetrated emerging markets in Asia,
Africa, and Latin America, focusing on countries with growing middle-class populations
and increasing demand for automobiles. The company has established manufacturing and
assembly plants in these regions to cater to local demands more effectively (Tata Motors,
2024).
Mahindra & Mahindra
Acquisitions and Investments:
• SsangYong Motor: Mahindra & Mahindra acquired the South Korean company
SsangYong Motor in 2010, which provided them with a foothold in the global SUV
market and access to advanced automotive technologies (Business Standard, 2010).
Expanding Product Lines:
• Tractors and Agricultural Equipment: Mahindra has focused on expanding its successful
tractor and agricultural equipment lines into international markets, particularly in the US,
China, and Africa, leveraging its strong domestic expertise and product reliability (The
Mahindra Group Official Website | Together We Rise, 2024).
Strategic Partnerships:
• Electric Vehicles (EVs): Mahindra has entered into several partnerships and joint
ventures to advance its EV technology and presence in the global market, including
collaborations with Volkswagen and other major automotive players (Devadiga, 2024).
Maruti Suzuki
Focus on Exports:
• SAARC and Africa: Maruti Suzuki has significantly increased its export volumes to
neighboring SAARC countries and Africa, leveraging its strong production base in India
to meet international demand (Kardar, 2011).
Technology and Collaboration:
• Suzuki Partnership: As a subsidiary of Suzuki Motor Corporation, Maruti Suzuki benefits
from the technology transfer and R&D capabilities of its Japanese parent. This
18
relationship has enabled Maruti Suzuki to develop models suited for international
markets and meet global standards.
Service Network Expansion:
• After-Sales Service: Maruti Suzuki has established a comprehensive after-sales service
network in its key export markets, ensuring customer satisfaction and loyalty abroad.
This strategic move helps maintain its market position and reputation internationally
(Nvadmin, 2023).
Table 9: Comparison of Global Expansion Strategies
Aspect
Tata Motors
Mahindra &
Maruti Suzuki
Mahindra
Strategic Acquisitions Acquired Jaguar
Acquired SsangYong
No significant
Land Rover (JLR) Motor for SUV market
acquisitions but
for luxury market
strong Suzuki
access
collaboration
Joint
Global alliances
Partnerships in EVs
Benefits from
Ventures/Partnerships with Fiat, Chinese with Volkswagen,
Suzuki’s technology
firms for EVs
others
and R&D
Market Penetration
Focus on
Expansion in US,
Increased exports to
emerging markets China, Africa with
SAARC and Africa
in Asia, Africa,
agricultural equipment
Latin America
Technology and
Enhanced tech
Investments in EV
Leverages Suzuki’s
Innovation
through JLR,
technology, renewable
R&D for global
focus on EVs
energy
standards
After-Sales Service
Developed local
Extensive service
Comprehensive
service networks
networks, particularly in after-sales service in
in key markets
rural areas
export markets
How have they entered new markets with new products, and how have they
retreated from some markets?
Tata Motors
Entering New Markets:
• Product Diversification: Tata Motors has entered new markets by diversifying its product
portfolio. For instance, the introduction of Tata Nano aimed at the lower-income segment
in emerging markets like India. This strategy helped Tata penetrate markets with high
price sensitivity (Hill et al., 2017).
• Acquisitions: The acquisition of Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) allowed Tata Motors to enter
the luxury vehicle markets in Europe and North America. This move provided access to
advanced automotive technologies and a premium customer base (Hill et al., 2017).
Retreat from Markets:
• Cost-cutting Measures: Tata Motors has retreated from certain markets as part of costcutting measures and to focus on more profitable regions. For instance, the company
scaled back operations in Thailand and Australia due to low demand and high operational
costs.
19
•
Discontinuation of Models: Tata Motors has also discontinued models that did not
perform well in specific markets, allowing the company to allocate resources more
effectively towards successful products.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Entering New Markets:
• Strategic Alliances: Mahindra has entered new markets through strategic alliances. For
instance, its joint venture with Ford to co-develop SUVs and electric vehicles (EVs) has
facilitated entry into North American and European markets (Devadiga, 2024).
• Expanding Product Lines: The introduction of new models like the Mahindra XUV500
and Thar has helped the company enter and establish a presence in new markets,
particularly in Africa and Latin America (Devadiga, 2024).
Retreat from Markets:
• Market Exit: Mahindra has exited markets where it faced sustained losses. For example,
it pulled out of the US truck market due to regulatory challenges and high competition
(Devadiga, 2024).
• Product Withdrawals: The company has also withdrawn specific products from markets
where they did not meet expected performance or sales targets, allowing for better focus
on profitable ventures.
Maruti Suzuki
Entering New Markets:
• Export Focus: Maruti Suzuki has primarily expanded into new markets through exports.
The company has focused on exporting affordable and fuel-efficient models to
neighboring countries in the SAARC region and Africa (Kardar, 2011).
• Technological Advancements: Leveraging its parent company Suzuki’s technology,
Maruti Suzuki has introduced new models with advanced features tailored to meet
international standards, thus facilitating entry into new markets.
Retreat from Markets:
• Market Withdrawal: Maruti Suzuki has selectively withdrawn from markets where it
struggled with profitability. For instance, the company reduced its focus on European
markets due to stringent emission norms and high competition.
• Model Discontinuation: Maruti Suzuki has discontinued models that did not perform well
in specific regions, redirecting resources towards more successful and strategic markets.
Aspect
Entering New
Markets
Retreat from
Markets
Table 10: Comparison of Entry and Exit Strategies
Tata Motors
Mahindra & Mahindra
Maruti Suzuki
Product
Strategic alliances (Ford),
Export focus to
diversification (Tata new models (XUV500,
SAARC, Africa,
Nano), JLR
Thar)
advanced technology
acquisition
models
Retreated from
Exited US truck market,
Reduced focus on
Thailand, Australia
product withdrawals
Europe, model
for cost-cutting
discontinuations
20
Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra, and Maruti Suzuki have each employed unique strategies to
enter new markets and introduce new products. While Tata Motors leverages acquisitions and
product diversification, Mahindra focuses on strategic alliances and new model introductions.
Maruti Suzuki primarily relies on exports and leveraging Suzuki’s technology. All three
companies have also strategically retreated from unprofitable markets to focus on more
promising regions and products.
How do the firms deal with foreign exchange?
Dealing with foreign exchange (forex) is crucial for multinational companies like Tata Motors,
Mahindra & Mahindra, and Maruti Suzuki. These firms employ various strategies to manage
currency risks and ensure financial stability.
Tata Motors
Hedging Strategies:
• Forward Contracts: Tata Motors uses forward contracts to lock in exchange rates for
future transactions. This helps mitigate the risk of currency fluctuations, particularly for
transactions involving the US dollar, euro, and British pound (Management Discussion
and Analysis | Tata Motors Annual Report 2013-14, n.d.).
• Options and Swaps: The company also employs currency options and swaps to hedge
against potential adverse movements in foreign exchange rates. These financial
instruments provide flexibility and protection against extreme volatility.
Natural Hedging:
• Revenue Diversification: By generating revenue in multiple currencies through its
international operations, Tata Motors achieves a natural hedge. For example, revenues
from Jaguar Land Rover in pounds and euros help balance the currency exposure from
imports and exports in different regions (Management Discussion and Analysis | Tata
Motors Annual Report 2013-14, n.d.).
Mahindra & Mahindra
Hedging Strategies:
• Forward Contracts and Futures: Mahindra & Mahindra actively uses forward contracts
and futures to hedge against currency risks. This approach helps stabilize cash flows and
predict financial outcomes despite exchange rate volatility (Arora & Etcfo, 2018).
• Currency Swaps: The company utilizes currency swaps to exchange debt obligations in
one currency for another, reducing the risk associated with long-term currency exposure
(Arora & Etcfo, 2018).
Operational Strategies:
• Local Sourcing: To minimize the impact of currency fluctuations, Mahindra & Mahindra
sources materials and components locally in the markets where they operate. This
reduces the need for cross-border transactions and associated forex risks (Arora & Etcfo,
2018).
• International Production Facilities: By establishing manufacturing units in key markets,
Mahindra can reduce the currency risk associated with exporting goods from India. This
also helps in optimizing supply chain costs.
21
Maruti Suzuki
Hedging Strategies:
• Forward Contracts: Maruti Suzuki employs forward contracts to hedge against short-term
foreign exchange risks, primarily concerning the Japanese yen and the US dollar. This
strategy helps stabilize procurement costs and revenue from exports (One, 2023).
• Natural Hedging through Exports: Since Maruti Suzuki exports a significant portion of its
production, the revenue earned in foreign currencies acts as a natural hedge against the
currency used for importing raw materials and components (One, 2023).
Operational Strategies:
• Localized Production: To mitigate forex risks, Maruti Suzuki has increased its focus on
localizing production. This reduces dependency on imported components and the
exposure to currency fluctuations (One, 2023).
• Collaboration with Suzuki: The strategic relationship with Suzuki Motor Corporation
provides Maruti Suzuki access to better forex management practices and technologies,
enhancing its ability to manage currency risks effectively (One, 2023).
Aspect
Hedging
Strategies
Natural
Hedging
Operational
Strategies
Table 11: Comparison of FOREX Strategies
Tata Motors
Mahindra & Mahindra
Forward contracts,
Forward contracts, futures,
options, swaps
currency swaps
Revenue
diversification
through international
operations
Extensive dealer and
service network in
international markets
Local sourcing,
international production
facilities
Maruti Suzuki
Forward contracts,
natural hedging
through exports
Export revenues,
collaboration with
Suzuki
Localized production,
reduced cross-border
transactions
Localized production
to reduce import
dependency
Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra, and Maruti Suzuki employ a combination of hedging
strategies and operational tactics to manage foreign exchange risks. Tata Motors and Mahindra
focus on forward contracts, options, and currency swaps, while also leveraging natural hedges
through revenue diversification and local sourcing. Maruti Suzuki uses forward contracts and
benefits from its strategic relationship with Suzuki for better forex management. Each company’s
approach reflects its specific market dynamics and operational priorities.
22
Organizational Management – Xiaoran
How have the firms established a supply-chain management system?
Tata Motors
Tata Motors has developed a comprehensive global supply chain management system to enhance
its manufacturing efficiency and market reach. The company’s supply chain extends globally,
with manufacturing facilities in India, the UK, South Korea, Thailand, South Africa, and
Indonesia. A significant boost to its supply chain capabilities came from the acquisition of Jaguar
Land Rover, which allowed Tata Motors to integrate advanced technologies and best practices in
supply chain management from the luxury vehicle segment. Tata Motors emphasizes strategic
partnerships and joint ventures to expand its capabilities. For instance, the joint venture with Fiat
provides access to advanced engine technology and increased production capacity. Furthermore,
Tata Motors has invested in in-house innovation, employing a platform-sharing system to reduce
costs and improve efficiency. The company also focuses on sustainability and localization,
minimizing environmental impact through green manufacturing practices and sourcing materials
locally to reduce costs and support local economies.1
Mahindra & Mahindra
Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M) operates an integrated supply chain network across various
sectors and countries. The company’s supply chain strategy includes strategic sourcing and
establishing long-term relationships with suppliers to ensure the procurement of high-quality
materials at competitive prices. M&M leverages advanced technologies such as automation,
robotics, and data analytics to enhance supply chain visibility and efficiency. Its R&D centers
focus on developing innovative solutions to improve supply chain processes, reduce costs, and
enhance product quality. Sustainability is a core component of M&M’s supply chain strategy,
with efforts to adopt eco-friendly materials, reduce waste, and optimize energy consumption.
Localization also plays a vital role, with the company sourcing materials locally to reduce
transportation costs and lead times while supporting local economies. Challenges such as
fluctuating raw material prices and regulatory changes are addressed through strategic planning
and continuous improvement initiatives.2
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki has established a robust supply chain management system supported by an
extensive network of suppliers. The company implements a Just-in-Time (JIT) manufacturing
system to minimize inventory levels and reduce production costs. Lean manufacturing principles
are adopted to eliminate waste, optimize processes, and enhance efficiency. Maruti Suzuki uses
advanced technologies such as data analytics, IoT, and automation to monitor and manage
supply chain activities in real-time, improving agility and responsiveness. Quality control
measures and continuous improvement initiatives are critical focuses, ensuring high standards
throughout the supply chain. The company also emphasizes sustainability, using eco-friendly
materials and local sourcing to reduce environmental impact and transportation costs. Maruti
Suzuki addresses challenges like supply chain disruptions and regulatory changes through
strategic planning and advanced technologies.3
1
Hill et al., 2017; Management Discussion and Analysis, n.d.; Tata Motors, 2024.
Devadiga, 2024; Financial Services, n.d.; Shastri, 2024.
3
Arora, n.d.; Nvadmin, 2023; Shastri, 2022.
2
23
How do the firms approach supply-chain management processes?
Tata Motors
Tata Motors employs a holistic approach to supply-chain management, integrating advanced
technologies and strategic partnerships to enhance efficiency. The company’s global
manufacturing network, which includes facilities in India, the UK, South Korea, Thailand, South
Africa, and Indonesia, enables it to leverage economies of scale. Strategic alliances, such as with
Fiat for engine technology and Marcopolo for commercial vehicles, expand its production
capabilities and technological access. Tata Motors also focuses on in-house innovation, using a
platform-sharing system to reduce costs and accelerate time-to-market. Sustainability and
localization are key priorities, with initiatives aimed at reducing environmental impact through
green manufacturing practices and sourcing materials locally to support local economies.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M) adopts an integrated approach to supply-chain management,
emphasizing strategic sourcing, technology utilization, and sustainability. The company
maintains long-term relationships with suppliers to ensure the procurement of high-quality
materials at competitive prices. M&M leverages advanced technologies such as automation,
robotics, and data analytics to enhance visibility and efficiency across its supply chain. Its R&D
centers focus on developing innovative solutions that improve processes, reduce costs, and
enhance product quality. Sustainability is a core component, with efforts to adopt eco-friendly
materials and optimize energy consumption. Localization is also emphasized, with the company
sourcing materials locally to reduce transportation costs and support local economies. M&M
addresses challenges such as fluctuating raw material prices and regulatory changes through
strategic planning and continuous improvement initiatives.
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki focuses on efficiency and quality in its supply-chain management processes,
utilizing an extensive supplier network critical for its Just-in-Time (JIT) manufacturing system.
This system minimizes inventory levels and reduces production costs. The company adopts lean
manufacturing principles to eliminate waste, optimize processes, and enhance efficiency.
Advanced technologies such as data analytics, IoT, and automation are used to monitor and
manage supply chain activities in real-time, improving agility and responsiveness. Quality
control measures and continuous improvement initiatives are integral, ensuring high standards
throughout the supply chain. Maruti Suzuki also emphasizes sustainability, using eco-friendly
materials and local sourcing to reduce environmental impact and transportation costs. Strategic
planning and advanced technologies are employed to address challenges like supply chain
disruptions and regulatory changes.
24
Do the firms have a solid global human resource management process?
Tata Motors
Tata Motors has developed a solid global human resource management (HRM) process to
support its extensive international operations. The company focuses on attracting, developing,
and retaining talent worldwide. Tata Motors emphasizes diversity and inclusion, ensuring that its
workforce reflects the global markets it serves. The company offers comprehensive training and
development programs to enhance employee skills and career growth, including leadership
development initiatives tailored for its international workforce. Tata Motors also implements
robust performance management systems to align employee objectives with organizational goals,
fostering a high-performance culture across its global operations. The company’s HRM strategies
are designed to support its strategic objectives, drive innovation, and maintain competitiveness in
the global automotive industry.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M) employs a comprehensive global HRM process that aligns with
its diverse business operations and international presence. The company focuses on talent
acquisition, development, and retention through various initiatives. M&M emphasizes leadership
development, offering programs that prepare employees for global roles. The company also
invests in continuous learning and development, providing training programs that enhance
technical and managerial skills. M&M promotes a culture of innovation and collaboration,
encouraging cross-functional and cross-geographical teamwork. The company’s HRM policies
support employee well-being, diversity, and inclusion, ensuring a supportive and dynamic work
environment. M&M’s HRM processes are integral to its strategy of maintaining a competitive
edge in various industries.
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki has established a robust HRM process to support its operations in India and its
growing international footprint. The company prioritizes employee development through
comprehensive training programs and leadership development initiatives. Maruti Suzuki’s HRM
strategies include a strong focus on performance management, aligning individual goals with
organizational objectives to drive high performance. The company also emphasizes employee
engagement, fostering a positive work environment that supports innovation and continuous
improvement. Maruti Suzuki’s HRM processes are designed to attract and retain top talent,
ensuring the company remains competitive in the automotive industry.
25
How do firms approach technological needs, intellectual capital resource
building, and management?
Tata Motors
•
•
•
Technological Needs: Tata Motors emphasizes integrating advanced technologies into
its operations. This includes adopting Industry 4.0 technologies such as automation, IoT,
and data analytics to enhance manufacturing efficiency and product quality.
Intellectual Capital Resource Building: The company invests in Research and
Development (R&D) centers worldwide, focusing on innovation and developing cuttingedge automotive technologies. Collaborative projects with global technology partners and
in-house innovation teams are key strategies.
Management: Tata Motors employs a centralized management approach to oversee
technological implementations and intellectual capital development, ensuring alignment
with corporate objectives and market demands.
Mahindra & Mahindra
•
•
•
Technological Needs: M&M focuses on leveraging advanced technologies across its
diverse business segments. The company adopts automation, robotics, and AI to
streamline operations and improve product offerings.
Intellectual Capital Resource Building: M&M invests heavily in R&D and encourages
a culture of innovation through initiatives like the Mahindra Research Valley. The
company fosters collaboration between its global R&D centers and external partners.
Management: M&M uses a decentralized management approach, empowering
individual business units to innovate and implement technologies while ensuring strategic
alignment with the company’s overall vision.
Maruti Suzuki
•
•
•
Technological Needs: Maruti Suzuki prioritizes adopting lean manufacturing
technologies and advanced analytics to enhance production efficiency and maintain highquality standards.
Intellectual Capital Resource Building: The company focuses on continuous employee
training and development programs to build intellectual capital. Partnerships with
academic institutions and global technology firms help drive innovation.
Management: Maruti Suzuki employs a hybrid management approach, balancing
centralized oversight with localized decision-making to adapt quickly to technological
advancements and market changes.
Aspect
Technological
Needs
Table 12: Comparison of Technical Resources
Tata Motors
Mahindra & Mahindra
Maruti Suzuki
Integrates Industry
Leverages automation,
Adopts lean
4.0 technologies like robotics, and AI across
manufacturing
automation, IoT, and business segments.
technologies and
data analytics.
advanced analytics.
26
Intellectual
Capital
Building
Invests in global
R&D centers and
collaborative
projects with
technology partners.
Management
Approach
Centralized
management to
oversee technology
and intellectual
capital development.
Invests in R&D,
encourages innovation
through Mahindra
Research Valley, and
fosters global
collaborations.
Decentralized
management
empowering business
units to innovate while
ensuring strategic
alignment.
Focuses on continuous
employee training,
partnerships with
academic institutions,
and global technology
firms.
Hybrid management
approach balancing
centralized oversight
with localized decisionmaking.
How did the adoption of new technologies by the firms impact their
technological structure and decision-making?
Tata Motors
•
•
Technological Structure: The adoption of Industry 4.0 technologies has led to a more
integrated and automated technological structure at Tata Motors. Advanced technologies
such as automation, IoT, and data analytics have been embedded across manufacturing
and operational processes, enhancing production efficiency and quality control.
Decision-Making: The integration of these technologies has improved data-driven
decision-making at Tata Motors. Real-time data analytics enables faster and more
informed decisions, reducing response times to market changes and operational
challenges. The centralized management approach ensures that technological
advancements are aligned with corporate strategies and objectives.
Mahindra & Mahindra
•
•
Technological Structure: The implementation of advanced technologies like
automation, robotics, and AI has significantly transformed M&M’s technological
structure. These technologies have been integrated across various business segments,
leading to streamlined operations and enhanced product offerings.
Decision-Making: The decentralized management approach at M&M empowers
individual business units to make decisions regarding technological implementations,
fostering innovation and agility. This approach allows for quicker adaptation to
technological advancements and market dynamics while ensuring alignment with the
company’s strategic vision.
Maruti Suzuki
•
Technological Structure: The adoption of lean manufacturing technologies and
advanced analytics has strengthened Maruti Suzuki’s technological structure. These
27
•
technologies have been crucial in maintaining high production efficiency and quality
standards, supporting the company’s leadership in the automotive market.
Decision-Making: Maruti Suzuki’s hybrid management approach balances centralized
oversight with localized decision-making, facilitating the rapid adoption of new
technologies. This structure ensures that decisions are both strategic and responsive to
on-the-ground realities, enhancing the company’s agility and competitive edge.
Aspect
Technological
Structure
DecisionMaking
Table 13: Comparison of Technical Structures
Tata Motors
Mahindra &
Maruti Suzuki
Mahindra
Integrated and
Transformed by
Strengthened with lean
automated with Industry automation, robotics,
manufacturing
4.0 technologies like
and AI across business technologies and
automation, IoT, and
segments.
advanced analytics.
data analytics.
Enhanced data-driven
Decentralized decision- Hybrid approach
decision-making with
making empowers
balancing strategic
real-time analytics and
business units, ensuring oversight with
centralized
agility and innovation. localized decisions for
management.
agility.
Has the firm embraced the concept of virtual teams in its operation?
Tata Motors
Tata Motors has embraced the concept of virtual teams to enhance its global operations and
collaboration. The company leverages digital tools and platforms to enable seamless
communication and coordination among its geographically dispersed teams. Virtual teams are
crucial for integrating global R&D efforts, especially after the acquisition of Jaguar Land Rover,
where cross-border collaboration is essential. Tata Motors uses virtual teams to manage projects,
share knowledge, and innovate, which has been particularly beneficial during the COVID-19
pandemic, ensuring continuity in operations and decision-making.
Mahindra & Mahindra
Mahindra & Mahindra (M&M) has adopted virtual teams as part of its strategy to enhance
flexibility and efficiency. The company utilizes virtual teams across its diverse business
segments to facilitate collaboration and innovation. Digital tools and platforms are used to enable
real-time communication, project management, and knowledge sharing among team members
located in different regions. Virtual teams help M&M to integrate its global operations, manage
cross-functional projects, and respond quickly to market changes. The adoption of virtual teams
has been instrumental in maintaining productivity and operational continuity during the
pandemic, supporting the company’s agile and decentralized management approach.
28
Maruti Suzuki
Maruti Suzuki has also integrated virtual teams into its operations to improve collaboration and
efficiency. The company employs virtual teams to manage various functions, including R&D,
marketing, and supply chain management. Digital collaboration tools facilitate communication
and coordination among team members across different locations. The use of virtual teams has
enabled Maruti Suzuki to streamline its operations, enhance decision-making, and maintain
business continuity during disruptions such as the COVID-19 pandemic. Virtual teams are a
critical component of Maruti Suzuki’s strategy to foster innovation and improve operational
agility.
Aspect
Use of
Virtual
Teams
Digital
Tools
Benefits
Pandemic
Response
Table 14: Comparison of Virtual Teams Concept
Tata Motors
Mahindra & Mahindra
Maruti Suzuki
Yes, for global R&D
Yes, across diverse
Yes, for managing
integration, project
business segments for
R&D, marketing, and
management, and
flexibility, efficiency, and supply chain functions.
knowledge sharing.
innovation.
Digital tools and
Digital tools for real-time Digital collaboration
platforms for seamless
communication, project
tools for
communication and
management, and
communication and
coordination.
knowledge sharing.
coordination.
Enhanced global
Improved flexibility,
Streamlined operations,
collaboration,
efficiency, productivity,
enhanced decisioninnovation, and
and response to market
making, and operational
operational continuity.
changes.
agility.
Ensured continuity in
Maintained productivity
Maintained business
operations and decision- and operational continuity continuity and fostered
making during COVID- during the pandemic.
innovation during
19.
disruptions.
29
References
Aicl. (2024, March 28). Tata Motors’ Shubhranshu Singh on the rise of influencers in marketing
strategies – Tata Motors. Tata Motors – Largest Automobile Manufacturer, Biggest
Automobile Company in India. https://www.tatamotors.com/blog/tata-motorsshubhranshu-singh-on-the-rise-of-influencers-in-marketing-strategies/
Arora, M., & Etcfo. (2018, August 23). Rupee’s volatility vs Tech Mahindra’s hedging policy.
Who will win? ETCFO.com. https://cfo.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/rupeesvolatility-vs-tech-mahindras-hedging-policy-who-will-win/65517759
Arora, L. (n.d.). Maruti Suzuki Distribution Channel. Scribd.

Broking, B. (2023, September 28). Mahindra Group- History, Major Subsidiaries & Major
Products | Bajaj Broking. https://www.bajajbroking.in/blog/mahindra-group
Business Standard. (2010, November 23). Mahindra buys 70% in SsangYong. www.businessstandard.com. https://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/mahindra-buys-70in-ssangyong-110112400046_1.html
Charging ahead – The Mahindra EV story. (2020, November 11).
https://www.mahindra.com/blogs/en/charging-ahead-the-mahindra-ev-story
Devadiga, K. (2024, February 16). Mahindra & Mahindra and Volkswagen forge alliance for
electric vehicle advancement – ET Edge Insights. ET Edge Insights. https://etinsights.etedge.com/mahindra-mahindra-and-volkswagen-forge-alliance-for-electric-vehicleadvancement/
Financial Services | Mahindra. (n.d.). https://www.mahindra.com/our-business/financialservices
30
Hill C. W. L., Schilling M. A. & Jones G. R. (2017). Strategic Management: An Integrated
Approach (Theory and Cases) (12th ed). South-Western Cengage Learning.
Kale, D., ESRC Innogen Centre, & Development Policy and Practise. (2011). Co-evolution of
policies and firm level technological capabilities in the Indian automobile industry. In
Atlanta Conference on Science and Innovation Policy.
https://oro.open.ac.uk/30555/1/428-1512-2-PB.pdf
Kardar, S. (2011). South Asia—Intraregional Cooperation: The Way forward.
https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/linked-documents/rcs-south-asia-2011-2015-oth02.pdf
Kumar, A., Kaur, P., & Geetika. (2021). Tata Motors JLR Reimagine Strategy. ResearchGate.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/367092668_Tata_Motors_JLR_Reimagine_Stra
tegy
Management Discussion and Analysis | Tata Motors Annual Report 2013-14. (n.d.).
https://investors.tatamotors.com/financials/69-ar-html/mda9.html
Nvadmin. (2023, May 5). How Maruti cars cater to the needs of Indian customers. Popular
Vehicles Services Ltd. https://www.popularmaruti.com/blog/how-maruti-cars-cater-tothe-needs-of-indian-customers/
One, A. (2023, October 5). Maruti Suzuki: Yen for success in a volatile foreign exchange
market. Angel One. https://www.angelone.in/blog/maruti-suzuki-yen-for-success-in-avolatile-foreign-exchange-market
Pti. (2023, January 12). Mahindra named fastest-growing brand in South Africa. The Economic
Times. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/auto/auto-news/mahindra-namedfastest-growing-brand-in-south-africa/articleshow/96929552.cms?from=mdr
31
Relationship with Supply Chain Partners | Tata Motors Annual Report 2016-17. (n.d.).
https://investors.tatamotors.com/financials/72-ar-html/relationship-supply-chain.html
Shastri, A. (2022, October 21). Full Maruti Suzuki Digital Marketing Strategy Case Study |
IIDE. IIDE. https://iide.co/case-studies/maruti-suzuki-marketing-strategy-case-study/
Shastri, A. (2024, May 11). Marketing Strategy of Mahindra and Mahindra – 2024 | IIDE. IIDE.

Detailed Marketing Strategy of Mahindra and Mahindra

Success story of Maruti Suzuki: A journey of innovation and market leadership. (n.d.).
https://brokerage-free.in/blogs/articles/success-story-of-maruti-suzuki-a-journey-ofinnovation-and-market-leadership
Tata Group. (2023). Tata Group Homepage | Tata Group. Tata.com. https://www.tata.com/
TATA MOTORS – 77th Integrated Annual Report 2021-22. (n.d.).
https://investors.tatamotors.com/financials/77-ar-html/index.html
Tata Motors. (2024, March 6). Innovations at Tata Motors | Future ready electric vehicles. Tata
Motors – Largest Automobile Manufacturer, Biggest Automobile Company in India.

Innovations

Tata Motors. (2024, March 6). Tata Motors | Connecting Aspirations | New-Age Mobility. Tata
Motors – Largest Automobile Manufacturer, Biggest Automobile Company in India.

Our global presence

The Mahindra Group official website | Together we rise. (2024, June 3).
https://www.mahindra.com/
Wikipedia contributors. (2024, June 3). Tata Motors. Wikipedia.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tata_Motors
32
Mahindra. (2024). Mahindra Rise – Mahindra Official Website | Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd.
Mahindra.com. https://www.mahindra.com/
Maruti Suzuki (2019). Marutisuzuki.com. https://www.marutisuzuki.com/